{"id":5450,"date":"2009-08-03T18:50:01","date_gmt":"2009-08-03T23:50:01","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/www.vanguardnewsnetwork.com\/v2\/?p=5450"},"modified":"2009-10-16T19:11:53","modified_gmt":"2009-10-17T00:11:53","slug":"ny-jewish-buisness-ethics-there-arent-any-jew-skank-bilks-million-from-corporate-america","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/www.vanguardnewsnetwork.com\/v2\/?p=5450","title":{"rendered":"NY: jewish business ethics: There aren&#8217;t any; Jew skank bilks million from corporate America"},"content":{"rendered":"<p>The alleged grifter who duped corporate giants<\/p>\n<p>(Fortune Magazine) &#8212; Just before dawn last October, around  50 federal law enforcement officials mustered in front of a six-story Beaux Arts  townhouse on Manhattan&#8217;s Upper West Side.<\/p>\n<p>The agents, wearing blue raid jackets, stood in the rain  outside the home of 45-year-old Dina Wein Reis, a self-described businesswoman,  film producer, and philanthropist. For at least 15 years Wein Reis had made a  fortune by allegedly gulling dozens of consumer product giants, including  Procter &amp; Gamble, Unilever, and Hershey, in exquisitely orchestrated scams.<\/p>\n<p>&#8220;We&#8217;re here to execute a search warrant,&#8221; an FBI agent said.  The agents swarmed into the first-floor salon, past the Modigliani portrait and  the French provincial furniture. They marched through sumptuous rooms crowded  with an eclectic collection of treasures, from La Farge stained-glass doors to  canvases by Warhol, Frank Stella, and Thomas Hart Benton.<\/p>\n<p>Wein Reis was arrested on charges of conspiracy and wire  fraud. After fainting, she was escorted by FBI agents to a hospital for  evaluation. Then she was arraigned, fingerprinted, photographed, and sent to  federal lockup. Five associates of Wein Reis were also arrested for their  alleged involvement in the fraud ring. The search warrant gave the government  authorization to seize &#8220;fruits of the crime,&#8221; which federal officials  interpreted to mean just about everything. Besides scores of necklaces and  watches, they carted off a pair of Louis XVI footstools, two Bugatti throne  chairs, a pair of Empire sleigh beds, and a 1920s cast-iron vanity.<\/p>\n<p><strong>The feds needed two huge moving vans to haul away the trove. <\/strong>The job wasn&#8217;t finished until three the next morning. The federal agents were  utterly overwhelmed by the quantities of loot. Recalled Dennis Halliden, the FBI  special agent supervising the case: &#8220;It was like King Tut&#8217;s tomb.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p><!--more--><\/p>\n<p>The grifter, wrote David Maurer in his classic 1940 study of  con men, &#8220;has a gentle touch.&#8221; He takes his &#8220;toll from the verdant sucker by  means of the skilled hand or the sharp wit &#8230; Of all the grifters, the  confidence man is the aristocrat.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>Dina Wein Reis certainly lived like gentry. <strong>She has  luxurious homes in Westhampton Beach, N.Y., Bal Harbor, Fla., and Jerusalem. <\/strong>Her  Manhattan townhouse was featured in <em>Architectural  Digest.<\/em> On a loan application she estimated her own net worth at $200  million, according to the government, although that figure is probably  exaggerated. She cultivated friendships in New York society, hosting lavish  parties for the Whitney Museum of American Art. With her polish, bling, and  porcelain skin, she made a striking first impression. Said one former employee:  &#8220;She looked like she stepped out of a Beyonc\u00e9 video.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>For sheer dollar damages, her alleged thievery cannot come  close to matching that of Bernard Madoff or R. Allen Stanford. She didn&#8217;t steal  outright, fudge the books, run a Ponzi scheme, or leave investors destitute. She  didn&#8217;t rob charities.<\/p>\n<p>But what she is accused of doing was fabulously brazen; she  had the temerity to sting some of the world&#8217;s biggest corporations &#8212; not just  once, but again and again. Her targets were middle- and upper-level marketing  executives, including division heads and presidents. It was a simple scheme,  though brilliantly choreographed, according to court records and people familiar  with the investigations. Here&#8217;s how it worked: Wein Reis persuaded the  executives to sell her merchandise at huge discounts, promising to include the  products in knapsacks or boxes of free samples to be handed out at schools,  senior centers, Native American reservations, or military bases. She promised  the sellers that if the sampling program were successful, the companies would  gain exclusive access to these hard-to-reach markets through her &#8220;National  Distribution Program.&#8221; But there was no National Distribution Program, according  to the deposition of a senior Wein Reis lieutenant. It was a fantasy. <strong>Instead,  Wein Reis and her team sold nearly all of the goods to middlemen, who sold them  to big retail chains, grocery stores, and wholesalers.<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>Wein Reis was what is known as a &#8220;diverter,&#8221; a player in the  little-known but large gray market in which consumer goods are bought and sold  in channels unauthorized by manufacturers. <strong>Diversion <a href=\"\/2009\/07\/31\/news\/companies\/product_diversion.fortune\/index.htm\">is not necessarily illegal<\/a>. But the way  Wein Reis did it was fraud, prosecutors allege.<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>Wein Reis, who faces trial in a federal court in  Indianapolis or New York sometime next year, declined to speak to Fortune. In a  statement, her lawyer, Michael Sommer, said, &#8220;Ms. Reis has pleaded not guilty to  the charges and fully expects to be vindicated. We share in her confidence, as  the notion that companies as sophisticated as those at issue in this case were  somehow deceived strains common sense.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>This account is based on court records; internal memos,  spreadsheets, and e-mails from Wein Reis&#8217;s companies; wiretap transcripts; and  interviews with former employees, targets, suppliers, family friends, and others  familiar with the civil and criminal litigation against her. Wein Reis, it  appears, is a person who thrives on complexity and illusion. <strong>She used multiple  aliases to run more than 100 shell companies. She tithed. She gave millions to  charities anonymously, <\/strong>yet she was often ungenerous with employees &#8212; a practice  that led to her downfall.<\/p>\n<p><!--startclickprintexclude-->Wein Reis worked hard for her money. She and her associates  would usually begin by cold-calling executives at big-brand companies, dangling  an offer of a high-paying job to replace her as the head of her conglomerate,  according to court records and interviews with former employees and people  familiar with the criminal investigation. Over the years, she paid for scores of  executives to fly to New York for these interviews.<\/p>\n<p><strong>At the right moment, with the executive believing that a job  offer was on the table, Wein Reis would ask him to arrange a shipment of  discounted merchandise from his current employer for her sampling program. Some  targets begged off, suspicious. Others shipped.<\/strong><\/p>\n<p><strong>The scores were big: Roche says Wein Reis bilked it out of  $10 million of diabetes-testing equipment. Unilever (<a href=\"http:\/\/money.cnn.com\/quote\/quote.html?symb=UL&amp;source=story_quote_link\">UL<\/a>) put its losses at $2.23 million in a  deal involving detergent. Procter &amp; Gamble (<a href=\"http:\/\/money.cnn.com\/quote\/quote.html?symb=PG&amp;source=story_quote_link\">PG<\/a>, <a href=\"http:\/\/money.cnn.com\/magazines\/fortune\/fortune500\/2009\/snapshots\/334.html?source=story_f500_link\">Fortune 500<\/a>) handed over several million  dollars&#8217; worth of shampoo. The government seeks to recover $20 million in  losses, but exactly how much money Wein Reis garnered from trickery is unclear<\/strong>.  The feds have uncovered more than 100 bank accounts, some overseas. In a  deposition in the late 1990s, Wein Reis testified under oath that her business  brought in between $20 million and $30 million in revenue in one year. A person  familiar with her companies&#8217; finances says that in the early part of this decade  she grossed $30 million to $35 million in an exceptional year, netting between  $12 million and $15 million.<\/p>\n<p>&#8220;Boy, was she good. To have been able to pull it off for at  least a decade!&#8221; says Donald deKieffer, a Washington, D.C., lawyer who monitors  diverters and counterfeiters, and who began tracking Wein Reis on behalf of  manufacturers in the early 1990s. DeKieffer calls Wein Reis&#8217;s alleged scheme one  of the most sophisticated he&#8217;s seen &#8212; &#8220;not because she did one thing  differently, but because she put it together in a really cool way.&#8221; Admits  deKieffer: &#8220;I have more than a grudging admiration for her.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>Wein Reis took advantage of the atomization of modern  corporations, where executives come and go and institutional memories are short.  Marketing officials, who tend to be more concerned with overall market share  than with customer relations, were favorite targets. Almost all were men. Wein  Reis employed a team of young women &#8212; many of them attractive and well educated  &#8212; to command their attention.<\/p>\n<p>&#8220;These were not boneheads,&#8221; says deKieffer. &#8220;These were not  bimbos. They were not relying on boobs, but brains.&#8221; Wein Reis and her damsels  of diversion inflated their targets&#8217; egos, got deep inside their heads, and  turned their critical-thinking powers to mush. &#8220;I would covet the opportunity  for you and me to carve out some quality time,&#8221; Robert Gregerson, then president  of Polaroid&#8217;s instant-camera division, wrote in 2006 after a New York meeting  with Wein Reis. &#8220;I am approaching this with full recognition and realistic  expectation that you will remain intimately involved. By now, I trust you know  my ego will support it!&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>T<strong>he game sometimes continued even once her marks cottoned to  her scheme. After the chief operating officer of Tom&#8217;s of Maine, the  personal-care products company, was told he&#8217;d been conned, he shot Wein Reis a  withering e-mail. She wrote back: &#8220;I got your e-mail, have you been drinking?  Sounds like you are having fun on vacation &#8230; I wish I were there with you &#8230;  Also sounds like you are clueless about this business opportunity &#8230; too much  sun?&#8221;<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>Wein Reis left her marks flat on their backs, gasping. She  had a genius for turning male vanity into cash.<\/p>\n<p>When Donald Dumoulin entered the lobby of the Mandarin  Oriental hotel off Columbus Circle in Midtown Manhattan, it didn&#8217;t occur to him  that he might be walking into a trap. It was an early spring day in 2006, and  the Roche Diagnostics vice president had just flown into New York for a job  interview.<\/p>\n<p>The courtship had begun the previous December with a call  from an executive recruiter, according to Dumoulin&#8217;s affidavit in a court  filing. The recruiter was doing a search for a CEO to replace the founder of a  privately owned conglomerate of 60 companies. Was Dumoulin interested? Yes, he  was.<\/p>\n<p>Soon he was talking to a person named <strong>Chaya,<\/strong> who described  herself as the conglomerate&#8217;s vice president. The enterprise was run, she told  him, by a wealthy and charismatic woman by the name of &#8220;Dee.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>Over two decades, Dee had built up a sizable enterprise that  included an advertising agency, an accounting firm, a reinsurance unit, and vast  real estate holdings. The jewel of the operation was a distribution business. A  philanthropist who had built hospitals and housing around the world, she wanted  to devote herself full-time to charitable activities. She wanted someone smart  to take over the business. A man with consumer brand experience. A man like  Dumoulin. Oh, and there would be an apartment in Manhattan, and the annual pay  would be very, very good. How good? &#8220;Multiple millions.&#8221; (Other executives were  offered $8 million over four years, plus an apartment and a huge golden  parachute.)<\/p>\n<p>In subsequent telephone chats Dumoulin learned more about  Dee&#8217;s core business. Chaya told him that the National Distribution Program was a  network of some 6,500 pharmacies through which manufacturers could get exclusive  distribution rights. Dee&#8217;s company would purchase goods from these manufacturers  at an 85% discount. The products would then be distributed in the stores in gift  bags as samples. If the sampling program were successful (and it almost always  was), the manufacturer would get access to those stores to sell merchandise at  full price, minus a small cash discount. Nearly 30 big time manufacturers, he  was told, had already signed up for the program.<\/p>\n<p>And Dee? In his two phone conversations with her, she&#8217;d  seemed delightful. True, it was a bit odd that she couldn&#8217;t remember which  industry associate had told her such good things about him. And in retrospect,  the fact that she wouldn&#8217;t tell him her last name should have set off alarm  bells. When Dumoulin asked, Dee told him she was a private person who liked to  keep a low profile.<\/p>\n<p>On the evening of his arrival, Dumoulin had dinner at the  Mandarin Oriental with Sara Golden, one of Dee&#8217;s top lieutenants. A marathon  runner, Golden was smart, slim, and blond, with wholesome good looks, and she  had a connection to Dumoulin&#8217;s home state, having graduated from Indiana  University. Dumoulin would remember her later as &#8220;attractive, articulate &#8230; and  very kind and personable.&#8221; Dee, Golden told him, was devoutly religious, and  maternal with her employees.<\/p>\n<p>The next morning Dumoulin visited Dee&#8217;s office in Midtown  Manhattan. There he met the acting CFO, who pegged the owner&#8217;s net worth at $2.5  billion. He met a man who claimed to serve as the head of her reinsurance  business, and another gentleman who said he presided over Dee&#8217;s Miami real  estate empire. (None of these people have been charged with wrongdoing.)<\/p>\n<p>Around 2 p.m. a car and driver took Dumoulin to Dee&#8217;s  townhouse. He sat in the parlor and waited 45 minutes for her to come  downstairs. &#8220;I&#8217;m sorry, I got lost in prayer,&#8221; she told him. They talked for two  hours. Dee said she wanted to give a huge portion of her wealth away to build  hospitals and housing for the poor in the Third World. Dumoulin met her husband,  David, and their three boys, one of whom played the piano for him. On his way  out, Dumoulin met a curator of the Whitney Museum, Barbara Haskell, who was on  the way in (Wein Reis served on the museum&#8217;s Chairman&#8217;s Council). Haskell says  she doesn&#8217;t recall the meeting, but it made an impression on the visitor from  Indiana.<\/p>\n<p>In June, Dee suggested that Dumoulin &#8220;check out&#8221; her  organization by trying the National Distribution Program and shipping some Roche  merchandise. Dumoulin felt uncomfortable pursuing the job while doing business  with Dee. It was a conflict of interest, and he said he&#8217;d ship only if the deal  was good for Roche. Dee assured him it would be.<\/p>\n<p>The courtship grew more intense. Dee told him she wanted to  give him a &#8220;big hug,&#8221; and looked forward to their becoming a &#8220;permanent couple.&#8221;  She flew Dumoulin and his wife, Lynda, to New York, where they toured  apartments. Dumoulin had lunch with Sara Golden, while Dee&#8217;s company treated  Lynda to a spa regimen. Then came dinner at Dee&#8217;s townhouse, served by her  personal chef, at a table overlooked by three Thomas Hart Benton paintings.  Afterward, Lynda Dumoulin pronounced Dee &#8220;one of the nicest people in the  world.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>In August, Donald Dumoulin called Dee to tell her he  wouldn&#8217;t take the job. He and Lynda had just bought a new house by a golf course  and the prospect of uprooting the family seemed overwhelming. Dee was  disappointed, but a month later Dumoulin was back in talks with her &#8212; not about  the job, but about a business deal. Dumoulin thought Dee&#8217;s National Distribution  Program might give Roche&#8217;s diabetes-equipment business access to thousands of  new outlets. Two senior Roche executives called references that Dee had  provided. The references assured Roche she was legitimate.<\/p>\n<p>In September 2006, Roche pulled the trigger and shipped  almost 189,000 pieces of equipment to one of Dee&#8217;s New Jersey warehouses. Wein  Reis told Dumoulin she was very happy with the shipment. And for good reason:  For $1.7 million she&#8217;d just landed $11.7 million worth of merchandise.<\/p>\n<p>Dumoulin had made the biggest mistake of his career. Soon  the stunned vice president learned that the woman he knew as Dee was alleged to  be a notorious product diverter. Her name was Dina Wein Reis. But who was she,  really? Was anything that Dumoulin had been told about her true?<\/p>\n<p>Born in 1964, Dina Wein grew up in a modest, two-family  house in the Midwood section of Brooklyn, a middle-class enclave. Her father,  Solomon Wein, owned an apparel business, and her mother, Vivian, taught public  high school. The girl who would grow up to have her own personal shopper, makeup  artist, and hairdresser was a tomboy, recalls her brother in an e-mail to  Fortune. &#8220;My mother would send her out brushed and clean, and she would climb  trees, play with every stray cat and dog, go on treasure hunts on the obsolete  train tracks by our house,&#8221; Hershel Wein wrote, adding that his sister &#8220;would  come home all the time with one sock up and one sock down.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>In 1981, Wein graduated from Bnos Leah Prospect Park  Yeshiva, an all-girls school. She attended, but did not graduate from, Brooklyn  College, where she met the man who would later become her husband, David Ruiz, a  Colombian native and a former star soccer player. Ruiz embarked on intense  religious studies and converted to Judaism. The two eventually married and  changed their names to Reis. David, who majored in physical education, at  various times held jobs in real estate and contracting and, once they had  children, stayed home. Dina received a degree in human development from Empire  State College in 1987.<\/p>\n<p>Around this time, while still an undergraduate, Wein Reis  was learning the ins and outs of the legitimate sampling business in a full-time  job at a company called Market Concepts Inc. The company was paid by Fortune 500  companies to distribute free samples of merchandise in college bookstores. Wein  Reis quickly impressed her boss as hard-working and bright.<\/p>\n<p>After nearly two years working for Market Concepts, she quit  abruptly to work for a competitor. Returning from vacation, her boss learned not  only that Wein Reis was gone but also that she was trying to take with her  Barnes &amp; Noble (<a href=\"http:\/\/money.cnn.com\/quote\/quote.html?symb=BKS&amp;source=story_quote_link\">BKS<\/a>, <a href=\"http:\/\/money.cnn.com\/magazines\/fortune\/fortune500\/2009\/snapshots\/10061.html?source=story_f500_link\">Fortune 500<\/a>), one of his main accounts.  &#8220;She said she didn&#8217;t want to stay in what I was doing. She had bigger and more  grandiose plans for herself,&#8221; recalls her boss, Jay Bernstein. &#8220;Nothing stood in  her way. I guess the word is &#8216;chutzpah.'&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>Wein Reis struck out on her own around 1991, when she  launched her own company, Collegiate Marketing. Collegiate invited manufacturers  to sell it samples at deep discounts, offering entr\u00e9e to the $60 billion college  marketplace. Collegiate promised to distribute the samples in knapsacks and tote  bags for students at college bookstores. Meanwhile, other companies owned by  Wein Reis offered similar programs for campgrounds and assisted-living  communities. Only a small amount of merchandise, if any, went to these niche  markets. Instead, nearly all of it was shipped via middlemen to major retailers.<\/p>\n<p>It wasn&#8217;t long before Wein Reis and her companies found  themselves in legal trouble. In 1995 three consumer product makers &#8212; Golden  Grain (maker of Rice-A-Roni), Hershey Foods (<a href=\"http:\/\/money.cnn.com\/quote\/quote.html?symb=HSY&amp;source=story_quote_link\">HSY<\/a>, <a href=\"http:\/\/money.cnn.com\/magazines\/fortune\/fortune500\/2009\/snapshots\/203.html?source=story_f500_link\">Fortune 500<\/a>), and Warner-Lambert (maker of  Hall&#8217;s Mentholyptus) &#8212; sued Collegiate separately, alleging that the company  had unlawfully diverted merchandise to retailers. All three suits were settled  for undisclosed amounts. Those early lawsuits provided valuable training for  Wein Reis. The first lesson: Litigation could be tiresome and costly, but in the  end it was just a nuisance. (Two sources familiar with the civil and criminal  investigations said Wein Reis was recorded later by an employee telling her  staff that litigation was only a cost of doing business.) Lesson 2: Wein Reis  was developing a reputation; she needed to be smarter.<\/p>\n<p>Soon Wein Reis added a twist to her enterprise: By dangling  a plush-paying job in front of the executive who would ultimately be asked to  sell a discounted product, she injected an element of conflict of interest into  the transaction. When the deal blew up, the executive might be too embarrassed  to make a stink.<\/p>\n<p><em>&#8220;Hi, This is ( ) calling from (company  name), a New York based company. <\/em><\/p>\n<p><em>The reason for my call is that upon  learning of your reputation, background, and experience, your credentials are  actually of great interest to our management team here at (company name)  &#8230;&#8221;<\/em><\/p>\n<p>The recruiting pitch was carefully scripted, according to  documents reviewed by Fortune. If the target asked, &#8220;Where did you get my name?&#8221;  the caller was instructed to reply, &#8220;Well, being that I&#8217;m in the human resources  department here, your name was actually passed down to me.&#8221; If the target asked  how long the search had been going on, the caller would answer, &#8220;We&#8217;ve been  looking for eight months now &#8230; time is so much of the essence.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>When the marks asked for references, they were put in touch  with people who secretly accepted payments from Wein Reis. One of the  references, Edward Falvo, a former Pharmacia brand manager, admitted to being  paid $2,000 a month for his services to Wein Reis. And what services exactly did  he provide? Falvo said in a deposition in a civil suit against Wein Reis that he  did Internet research for reports, but said he never bothered to type them up.  Falvo declined to talk to Fortune. Another reference giver, Steve Manenti, was  indicted for his role in the alleged fraud. Other people were also paid for  role-playing. Thom Dean, an advertising executive, was paid several hundred  dollars to meet with recruiting targets, according to two of Wein Reis&#8217;s former  employees. Dean told Roche&#8217;s Dumoulin that he had sold a majority of his  advertising business to Wein Reis, according to a sworn affidavit by Dumoulin.  In an interview with Fortune, Dean said he had discussed selling the business to  Wein Reis but hadn&#8217;t done so. He said he had met with Wein Reis prospects, had  let Wein Reis characterize him in these meetings as a &#8220;marketing partner,&#8221; and  had been paid for his time. But he said he never explicitly misrepresented  himself. &#8220;I never understood until the very end what she was doing,&#8221; Dean said,  adding that when he&#8217;d try to pin her down, she&#8217;d change the subject. &#8220;You&#8217;d  never get an answer.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>To further the illusion alleged in court documents that she  had a stable of Fortune 500 clients, Wein Reis employed another clever ruse: the  Potemkin store. When Wein Reis was courting an executive, an assistant would  take him to a small store, usually in New Jersey, telling him it was part of her  National Distribution Program. The executive would see shelf upon shelf of goods  made by companies supposedly in the program, given premium display and  preferential pricing. He might see his own company&#8217;s products too &#8212; poorly  displayed and marked up 60%.<\/p>\n<p>What the executive didn&#8217;t know was that Wein Reis had made a  deal with the store owner in advance in which he agreed to let her rearrange his  shelves for a day in exchange for stocking the store with other merchandise.<\/p>\n<p>For many years Wein Reis occupied an office on Manhattan&#8217;s  East 58th Street. In the lobby the only mention of the firm was Truffle  Holdings, the entity that leased the office. Upstairs, placards with different  company names were slipped into the slot on the left side of the double-door  entrance, depending on which corporate target was visiting that day, according  to former employees. Some 20 to 25 phone lines were active at a time, each  assigned to a different company.<\/p>\n<p>Wein Reis&#8217;s team tracked calls with spreadsheets that logged  which executives were being pitched and noted whether they had met with Wein  Reis&#8217;s staff. The most frequent entry in the notes section was &#8220;Not interested.&#8221;  Another common entry: &#8220;Skeptical.&#8221; Next to the makers of Melitta coffee filters,  a Wein Reis salesperson wrote, &#8220;Now hate us.&#8221; &#8220;We are on some sort of Diverters  list,&#8221; said the notation next to a canned-goods marketing official for Del Monte  Foods (<a href=\"http:\/\/money.cnn.com\/quote\/quote.html?symb=DLM&amp;source=story_quote_link\">DLM<\/a>). The official&#8217;s dry observation as  duly noted by the Wein Reis employee: &#8220;Her face should be on a milk carton.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>But for every 50 people who said no, there were a dozen or  so who&#8217;d nibble on the bait. Douglas Ehrenkranz, a former vice president at  Imperial Sugar (<a href=\"http:\/\/money.cnn.com\/quote\/quote.html?symb=IPSU&amp;source=story_quote_link\">IPSU<\/a>), recalls meeting in New York with  Wein Reis and her associates to talk about a job. &#8220;I remember saying, &#8216;This is  too good to be true &#8212; something&#8217;s not right here,'&#8221; says Ehrenkranz. &#8220;The bad  news is, I didn&#8217;t smell the scam. The good news is, I didn&#8217;t sell her product.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>Dozens of other executives fell for the ruse. Afterward they  would often find themselves unable to sell to existing customers because the  market had been flooded with diverted goods. Some companies shrugged it off, but  others reacted with rage. &#8220;I think the panic you hear in my voice is simply due  to the fact that I need to speak with you directly, and for some reason I  haven&#8217;t been able to do that,&#8221; a desperate GlaxoSmithKline vice president wrote  to one of Reis&#8217;s minions after he realized the company stood to lose $1 million  because of the scheme.<\/p>\n<p>In at least one remarkable way, Wein Reis did not fit the  profile of a pure hustler. A person familiar with her finances says she gave at  least 10% of her profits to charity. She regularly hosted homeless people in her  townhouse. When an Israeli rabbi called her about the death of a man in his  congregation in a suicide bombing, Wein Reis sent the rabbi a big check but  insisted the gift be anonymous. That was common practice, recalls Marvin Schick,  a close family friend, who says Reis gave &#8220;many hundreds of thousands of  dollars&#8221; to yeshivas. &#8220;In all my dealings with her on charitable matters, she  never once indicated she wanted recognition.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>The arts were another passion. She helped finance <em>Carpati<\/em>, a low-budget film partly narrated by Leonard  Nimoy, about a Ukrainian ice-cream seller who returns to his village 50 years  after the Holocaust. She also helped produce a Broadway adaptation of <em>On the Waterfront<\/em>, which flopped. To renovate her  townhouse, which was built in the mid-1890s, she hired noted interior designer  Samuel Botero. An article about the home, titled &#8220;Eclectic Defined,&#8221; was  published by <em>Architectural Digest<\/em> last January (after  Wein Reis had been indicted). The home, it said, was filled with treasures from  old residences in France and elsewhere. The house contained a dizzying array of  styles, from Victoriana to Art Deco. Wein Reis even had the graffiti artist  Crash put a tag on her elevator.<br \/>\nWein Reis was hard on her staff. Few  employees lasted a year; some were hired in the morning and fired by day&#8217;s end.  &#8220;Dina went through assistants like toilet paper,&#8221; recalls one employee who was  fired. Her behavior could swing from empathy to callousness in an instant. One  worker took a Thursday and Friday off to attend her grandfather&#8217;s funeral and  received a call from Wein Reis the following Monday: &#8220;I&#8217;m sorry about your  grandfather. You&#8217;re fired.&#8221; A weeping assistant recounted to the company&#8217;s top  finance official that Wein Reis had once handed her a pair of dirty panties and  ordered her to put them in the hamper.<\/p>\n<p>Irith Hayblum started working for Wein Reis in 2000. An  Australian \u00e9migr\u00e9e and a mother of two, Hayblum had been a teacher at the  yeshiva Wein Reis&#8217;s kids attended. She was religious and hard-working. Hayblum  started out helping create and manage databases. Eventually she was made  director of marketing and put in charge of the Potemkin stores. In November  2004, Hayblum was asked to write a letter to a customer explaining how the  products it had shipped were to be distributed. She made the mistake of telling  the truth: She wrote a letter explaining that 1% to 1.5% of the products would  be sent to the sampling program, according to people familiar with the matter.  Sara Golden, her boss, was furious, scolding her for giving the client the  accurate figure and saying the clients believed all the products would go to the  sampling program. Around this time Hayblum started getting calls from Unilever,  which wanted to talk to Golden about a shipment of detergent that a Wein Reis  company had received. Hayblum was instructed to say, falsely, that Golden had  left the company.<\/p>\n<p>Hayblum injured her foot buying groceries to stock the  stores. A few days later, in February 2005, she was abruptly fired. Hayblum  wrote letters to Unilever, Tom&#8217;s of Maine, Kashi, and other companies telling  them they had been defrauded by Wein Reis. She also set up a website containing  allegations against her former employer, giving her the title &#8220;The Queen of  Scam.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>Tom O&#8217;Brien, then COO of Tom&#8217;s of Maine (now its CEO), wrote  an angry e-mail to Wein Reis in March 2005, saying, &#8220;The gig is up.&#8221; Wein Reis  talked him down from the ledge, explaining that Hayblum was an &#8220;emotionally ill  individual&#8221; trying to blackmail her.<\/p>\n<p>O&#8217;Brien started getting calls from other companies that said  they&#8217;d been defrauded. He went ballistic. &#8220;Goodbye,&#8221; he wrote Wein Reis. &#8220;The  discussions help us see the real deal and deceptions &#8230; No more smoke and  mirrors, please &#8230; I&#8217;ll be praying for you.&#8221; (O&#8217;Brien declined to discuss the  matter with Fortune.)<\/p>\n<p>Unilever decided to take Wein Reis to court. The Anglo-Dutch  conglomerate turned to Rod Brown, a former Manhattan assistant district attorney  and trial lawyer. Brown had been one of Wein Reis&#8217;s most persistent antagonists,  having been the lead lawyer in several lawsuits and claims against her dating to  the mid-1990s. Each suit had settled before trial. Realizing that piecemeal  litigation wasn&#8217;t going to stop Wein Reis, Brown put together a civil RICO  claim, alleging Wein Reis and her associates had engaged in a pattern of fraud.  Unilever filed suit in November 2005.<\/p>\n<p>To win a civil racketeering case, Unilever would have to  show that Wein Reis was running a criminal enterprise and that there had been  multiple instances of fraud. Brown interviewed executives who had been lured to  New York with phony job offers. The case was complicated by the fact that Wein  Reis&#8217;s marketing materials to manufacturers included language that mentioned a  &#8220;wholesalers&#8221; program. Furthermore, Wein Reis&#8217;s lawyers produced letters from  her that seemed to spell out that only a fraction of any merchandise received  would be going to the sampling program, and that the rest was going to  diverters. If the letters had really been sent, they could have spelled defeat  for Unilever. But executive after executive claimed never to have received them.  In fact, there were numerous signs that the letters had never been sent. Some  had been misaddressed. Others used Wein Reis&#8217;s full name when the executives had  known only her nicknames. &#8220;This was the meta-fraud,&#8221; said Brown. &#8220;When you have  10 people at 10 different companies saying they&#8217;d never seen the letters, it  suggests they never went out.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>It was while the Unilever case was under way that Donald  Dumoulin was negotiating with the woman he knew as Dee about a shipment of  diabetes-testing equipment. Even before the merchandise had been shipped, the  head of security at Roche Diagnostics, Max Brenton, had been wary of the  transaction. It just didn&#8217;t smell right. What seemed oddest was how little  public information he could find about the New York company. There wasn&#8217;t even a  website. But a lack of information wasn&#8217;t enough for the security man to stop  the deal, and besides, Dumoulin and the other executives had vetted it.<\/p>\n<p>Not long after the shipment was made, Brenton, a former  Indianapolis police detective who had served in an organized-crime unit, got a  call from a counterpart at Walgreen. Someone was trying to sell the drug chain a  big shipment of diabetes equipment. Did Roche know about this?<\/p>\n<p>Then Brenton found out about the Unilever lawsuit. This  wasn&#8217;t just a small-time diverter, he believed: It was a giant diversion ring.  Dumoulin, who would lose his job partly for his role in the matter, was  shattered. Brenton kept digging. He pushed Roche to pursue the matter. In  January 2007, Roche sued in federal court and settled a month later.<\/p>\n<p>Dennis Halliden, an FBI special agent in Indianapolis, read  a small article about the suit in a local paper. Halliden&#8217;s interest was more  than piqued. He called Roche&#8217;s outside lawyer, Irvin Nathan, who told him that  this was a major scam. A month earlier Nathan had gone to the Department of  Justice&#8217;s fraud section, which had also begun to pursue the matter. Halliden  became the lead investigator in the case.<\/p>\n<p>The government persuaded a judge to grant a wiretap. Federal  officials intercepted around 4,000 phone calls. They heard hours and hours of  Wein Reis haranguing her staff to perfect their sales pitches. The tapes, say  people who have seen the transcripts, are damning. &#8220;What will hurt each and  every one of the ladies the worst is the seeming indifference they have,&#8221; says  one person who has read the transcripts. &#8220;That&#8217;s something that&#8217;s not going to  sit right with a jury.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>After the raid on her townhouse, Wein Reis spent an  uncomfortable week in the same federal lockup facility that six months later  would become the temporary home of Bernard Madoff. A judge released her after  her brother Hershel Wein, a tax lawyer at the white-shoe firm of Dewey &amp;  LeBoeuf, helped raise the $10 million bail. She is now back in the mansion,  though it is in foreclosure.<\/p>\n<p>Wein Reis has been battling the government on multiple  fronts. Her lawyers have persuaded the government to return some of her personal  property, including wedding rings, her sons&#8217; bar mitzvah watches, and her  father&#8217;s Phi Beta Kappa key. Most of her art collection remains in federal  custody, but 15 paintings were turned over to Unilever, which settled its case  with Wein Reis for an undisclosed sum that is reported to be in the multiple  millions of dollars.<\/p>\n<p>Wein Reis enlisted her rabbi in her bid to convince a judge  that she should not be required to wear an electronic monitoring ankle bracelet.  Orthodox practice, the rabbi said, forbids women from wearing slacks or  pantsuits. Summer was coming, Wein Reis&#8217;s lawyer noted, and any skirt or dress  shorter than ankle length would reveal the bracelet, which would complicate her  efforts to get a new job. The judge agreed.<\/p>\n<p>Four of the five other people charged for their roles in the  alleged fraud worked directly for Wein Reis: Suzanne Carrico, Sara Golden,  Sheryl Raport, and Chaya Cooper. All but Carrico were charged with six counts of  wire fraud and a single count of conspiracy; Carrico was charged only with  conspiracy. A fifth person, Steve Manenti, who according to the indictment gave  references for Wein Reis, was charged with seven criminal counts. Lawyers for  Cooper, Golden, Raport, and Manenti declined to comment on the allegations. A  lawyer for Carrico could not be reached for comment as this story went to press.<\/p>\n<p>Wein Reis&#8217;s legal team declined to discuss her defense, but  those who know her say there&#8217;s little chance she&#8217;ll cop a plea. In this legal  battle it wouldn&#8217;t be hard to cast Wein Reis as the underdog. In one corner  stands a lineup of aggrieved multinational companies; in the other corner, a  self-made woman, a prayerful philanthropist, a mother of three. To which there  is a likely government rejoinder: Free markets wither when trust is broken.<\/p>\n<p>And, of course, it wasn&#8217;t all illusion: Real lives were  affected by the alleged fraud. Scott Weintraub, a former Pharmacia manager,  endured a grueling internal investigation after the company learned it had been  duped. A company lawyer, he recalls, was convinced &#8212; wrongly, it turned out &#8212;  that he&#8217;d had a romantic relationship with a fetching Wein Reis associate.<\/p>\n<p>Eighteen months after the scam was discovered, he says, he  was still getting dinged on performance reviews. What bothered him most, he  says, was that the president of his division believed he was either a fool or  unethical. &#8220;Most of the time I think he thought I was an idiot,&#8221; Weintraub says.  &#8220;They don&#8217;t fire people for being stupid, luckily.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>Sometimes they do. No one knows for certain how many  executives lost their jobs after getting caught in Wein Reis&#8217;s web. Roche&#8217;s  Dumoulin did. So did a longtime Unilever executive.<\/p>\n<p>&#8220;It was a hand grenade in the pocket,&#8221; says the FBI&#8217;s Dennis  Halliden. &#8220;Careers were destroyed. These executives were hosed.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>Don deKieffer, the lawyer who pursued Wein Reis for years,  says that companies will always be susceptible to such schemes as long as  executives are so trusting. &#8220;In almost every case you had people inside the  company not paying attention to the good of the entire enterprise,&#8221; says  deKieffer. &#8220;There are bad people out there &#8212; wolves who will eat you unless you  pay attention. <strong>Dina is a wolf, and she happily chomped away at these companies.<\/strong>&#8221;  \u00a0<a href=\"#TOP\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" src=\"http:\/\/i.cdn.turner.com\/money\/images\/bug.gif\" border=\"0\" alt=\"To top of page\" width=\"7\" height=\"7\" \/><\/a><\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>The alleged grifter who duped corporate giants (Fortune Magazine) &#8212; Just before dawn last October, around 50 federal law enforcement officials mustered in front of a six-story Beaux Arts townhouse on Manhattan&#8217;s Upper West Side. The agents, wearing blue raid jackets, stood in the rain outside the home of 45-year-old Dina Wein Reis, a self-described [&hellip;]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":6,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[241,571,1016,174],"tags":[],"class_list":["post-5450","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-jewish-criminality","category-jewish-organizations","category-jewish-power","category-jewish-scam-artists"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.vanguardnewsnetwork.com\/v2\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/5450","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.vanguardnewsnetwork.com\/v2\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.vanguardnewsnetwork.com\/v2\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.vanguardnewsnetwork.com\/v2\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/users\/6"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.vanguardnewsnetwork.com\/v2\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcomments&post=5450"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/www.vanguardnewsnetwork.com\/v2\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/5450\/revisions"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.vanguardnewsnetwork.com\/v2\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fmedia&parent=5450"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.vanguardnewsnetwork.com\/v2\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcategories&post=5450"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.vanguardnewsnetwork.com\/v2\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Ftags&post=5450"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}