{"id":988,"date":"2006-08-24T15:40:49","date_gmt":"2006-08-24T20:40:49","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/www.vanguardnewsnetwork.com\/v2\/?p=988"},"modified":"2006-08-24T16:00:08","modified_gmt":"2006-08-24T21:00:08","slug":"omeara-the-origins-of-racial-nationalism-in-america","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/www.vanguardnewsnetwork.com\/v2\/?p=988","title":{"rendered":"O&#8217;Meara: The Origins of Racial Nationalism in America"},"content":{"rendered":"<p align=\"left\">Klansmen, Irishmen, and Nativists:<br \/>\nThe Origins of Racial Nationalism in  America<\/p>\n<div align=\"left\"><\/div>\n<p>by Michael O&#8217;Meara<\/p>\n<p><!--more--><\/p>\n<p>The heterogeneity of America&#8217;s European  population has<br \/>\nalways posed a challenge to its national identity.<br \/>\nOnly  late in the 19th century was this identity<br \/>\nextended to European immigrants  assimilated in its<br \/>\nAnglo-Protestant values and, in the 20th century,  to<br \/>\nCatholics, whose Church (the &#8220;Whore of Babylon&#8221;) had<br \/>\nlearned to  accommodate the Protestant contours of<br \/>\nAmerican life (or what John Murray  Cuddihy called its<br \/>\n&#8220;civil religion&#8221;).  From this ethnogenesis,  the<br \/>\noriginal Anglo-Protestant identity of the American<br \/>\npeople gradually  evolved into a more inclusively<br \/>\nEuropean Christian identity, though one  closely tied<br \/>\nto its Anglo-Protestant antecedents.  Based on this<br \/>\nheritage,  racial nationalists today define America as<br \/>\na European nation and designate  its anti-White elites<br \/>\nas their principal enemy.<\/p>\n<p>It was, though, but in  fits and starts that American<br \/>\nWhites acquired an ethnonational identity.   What&#8217;s<br \/>\noften referred to as American nationalism &#8212; the<br \/>\nexpansionist  slogans of Manifest Destiny, the ideology<br \/>\nof Anglo-Saxonism, the gunboat  diplomacy of the<br \/>\nProgressives (McKinley, T. Roosevelt, Wilson) &#8212; was<br \/>\nmore  a chauvinist statism legitimating territorial<br \/>\nexpansionism and land  speculation than an ideological<br \/>\noffshoot of the country&#8217;s racial-historical  life<br \/>\nforms.  The primordial concerns of the American nation<br \/>\nwere thus only  tangentially represented in these<br \/>\nimperialist movements associated with the  state&#8217;s<br \/>\nexpansion.<\/p>\n<p>The first genuinely post-revolutionary expression  of<br \/>\nAmerican ethnonationalism (i.e., &#8220;nationalism in its<br \/>\npristine sense&#8221;)  began, revealingly, with the first<br \/>\nwave of mass immigration, in the late  1830s and in<br \/>\n&#8220;the hungry Forties,&#8221; as Irish and South German<br \/>\nCatholics  reached American shores, affronting<br \/>\n&#8220;Anglo-Americans&#8221; with their  &#8220;otherness.&#8221;  The<br \/>\n&#8220;nativists&#8221; (native born, White, Protestant  Americans)<br \/>\nopposing the new immigrants rejected the crime,  public<br \/>\ndrunkenness, and pauperism the Irish brought, but<br \/>\nabove all the  Catholicism of both groups, for &#8220;the<br \/>\nChurch of Rome&#8221; was an anathema to a  liberal nation<br \/>\nborn of the Reformation and of the struggle against<br \/>\nthe  Catholic empires of Spain and France.  The<br \/>\nnativist response was nevertheless  a nuanced one<br \/>\nrecognizing the distinctions that culturally  separated<br \/>\nIrishmen from Germans.  The latter, who began to<br \/>\noutnumber the  Irish only in the late 1850s, tended to<br \/>\nbe farmers and artisans.  That they  settled inland,<br \/>\naway from the older coastal settlements, and engaged<br \/>\nin  respectable occupations also mitigated nativist<br \/>\nopposition, although  nativists opposed the formation<br \/>\nof German-speaking communities, beer-drinking  forms of<br \/>\nsociability, and the Germans&#8217; political radicalism.<br \/>\nThe Germans  nevertheless seemed assimilable, which was<br \/>\nnot the case with the Irish.  The  first expression of<br \/>\nAmerican nativism was thus largely an  anti-Irish<br \/>\nmovement, for the tribal solidarity of this<br \/>\nunbourgeois people,  their aggressive rejection of<br \/>\nProtestant culture, especially as propagated in  the<br \/>\npublic schools, their whiskey drinking and pre-modern<br \/>\nbehavior, and  their anti-liberal sympathy for the<br \/>\nslave states (which nativists resented  because these<br \/>\nstates closed off land for White settlement) were an<br \/>\noffense  to the country&#8217;s Anglo-Protestant culture.<br \/>\nThis anti-Irish sentiment became  especially prominent<br \/>\nonce the famine ships, with their destitute  cargoes,<br \/>\nbegan arriving.<\/p>\n<p>The Irish, though, offended not simply the  Yankees&#8217;<br \/>\nreligious and behavioral standards, their exploitation<br \/>\nof the  political system offended their republican<br \/>\nconvictions.  Though one of the  most afflicted of<br \/>\nEurope&#8217;s nations, Erin&#8217;s exiles were also one of  the<br \/>\nmost politically &#8220;advanced.&#8221;  Not only had they a long<br \/>\nhistory of  secret societies (such as the Defenders,<br \/>\nWhiteboys, Ribbonmen, etc.), which  had waged an<br \/>\nunderground war against English landlords and<br \/>\nOrangemen, in  the 1820s, Daniel O&#8217;Connell&#8217;s Catholic<br \/>\nAssociation, &#8220;the first mass political  party in<br \/>\nhistory,&#8221; taught the Irish how to exploit the new<br \/>\nelectoral forms  of liberal parliamentary politics in<br \/>\norder to throw off England&#8217;s Protestant  Ascendancy and<br \/>\nits genocidal Penal Laws.  In America, the  politically<br \/>\nsavvy Irish (led by their priests, saloon keepers,  and<br \/>\neloquent rebels) challenged not just Yankee folkways,<br \/>\nbut the  individualistic tenor of republican<br \/>\ngovernance.  The terrible age of American  ethnic<br \/>\npolitics begins with the Irish.<\/p>\n<p>From the 1830s through to the  late 1850s, nativist<br \/>\nopposition to Catholic, specifically  Irish,<br \/>\nimmigration took the form of intercommunal strife,  the<br \/>\nproliferation of anti-immigrant associations, and,<br \/>\nthen in 1854, the  establishment of a national<br \/>\npolitical party &#8212; the American party (known as  the<br \/>\n&#8220;Know-Nothings&#8221;) &#8212; which, for a time, became a refuge<br \/>\nfor  abolitionist and free-soil opponents of Southern<br \/>\nslavery who had broken with  the Whig party but not yet<br \/>\naffiliated with the newly formed Republican  party.<br \/>\nAs a movement, the Know Nothings held that<br \/>\nProtestantism was an  essential component of American<br \/>\nidentity; that Catholicism&#8217;s &#8220;autocratic&#8221;  Pope and<br \/>\nChurch hierarchy were incompatible with republican<br \/>\nself-rule;  that Catholics had acquired undue political<br \/>\nadvantage; and that a longer,  more thorough process of<br \/>\nnaturalization (or Americanization) was necessary  for<br \/>\nthe acquisition of citizenship.  More fundamentally,<br \/>\nit gave  expression to the deep reservation which<br \/>\nAnglo-American Protestants had about  allowing their<br \/>\ncountry to be overrun by Catholic immigrants.  Like<br \/>\nmost  future manifestations of American racial<br \/>\nnationalism (though they lacked a  genuinely racial<br \/>\ndimension), the Know Nothings were moved by a  populist<br \/>\ndistrust of the state and the established political<br \/>\nparties,  which were seen as indifferent to the<br \/>\ncommunal and ethnic needs of native  Whites.<\/p>\n<p>Within but a year of its founding, the American  party<br \/>\nsucceeded in electing eight state governors, more than<br \/>\na hundred  Congressmen, the mayors of Boston,<br \/>\nPhiladelphia, and Chicago, and thousands  of local<br \/>\nofficials.  Its future looked bright.  But the party<br \/>\nfell almost  as rapidly as it rose, having been swept<br \/>\nup and then forced off the political  stage by powerful<br \/>\nsectional conflicts related to slavery and  the<br \/>\npreservation of the Union.  Its struggle for an<br \/>\nAnglo-Protestant  America in the 1850s nevertheless<br \/>\nrepresented the first bloom of American  nationalism in<br \/>\nits blood-and-soil stage (somewhat earlier than  other<br \/>\nEuropean nationalisms, which were still at the liberal<br \/>\npolitical  stage).  As such, it resisted a political<br \/>\nsystem privileging economics over  community,<br \/>\nopportunity over belief, and a liberal over a<br \/>\nbiocultural  understanding of American life.  Though<br \/>\nrace was not an issue, religion,  culture, and an<br \/>\nendogamous sense of community were &#8212; issues that  are<br \/>\npreeminently ethnonationalist.  Nativism became, as<br \/>\nsuch, the  foundation upon which the future defense of<br \/>\nEuropean life in America would be  waged &#8212; for in<br \/>\nhowever rudimentary and unfocused a way, it defended<br \/>\nthe  American nation as an English and Protestant<br \/>\ncommunity of descent, not a  political entity based on<br \/>\nan abstract ideological or creedal notion  of<br \/>\nnationality opened to all the world.<\/p>\n<p>The racial component of this  biocultural definition of<br \/>\nthe nation would come into its own in the  anti-Chinese<br \/>\nmovement that dominated California politics in the<br \/>\nhalf  century following the Gold Rush (1848).  As<br \/>\nEuropean immigrants, native  Americans, and the first<br \/>\nChinese made their way to California in this  period,<br \/>\nso too did racial conflict &#8212; though conflict here was<br \/>\nnot between  natives and immigrants, but between<br \/>\nOccidentals and Orientals.  Against the  first Chinese<br \/>\narrivals and the swarming millions threatening to<br \/>\nfollow in  their wake, native Americans and European<br \/>\nimmigrants discovered their common  racial identity.<br \/>\nAlmost from the start, they recognized the joint  stake<br \/>\nthey had in opposing a people which worked at half the<br \/>\nWhite man&#8217;s  wage, retained their alien clothes,<br \/>\ncustoms, and language, practiced a  &#8220;heathen&#8221; religion,<br \/>\nand formed distinct, often self-contained  communities<br \/>\nassociated with vice and disease.  Comprising a fifth<br \/>\nof the  California labor force in the 1870s, these<br \/>\nChinese newcomers, with their low  living standards and<br \/>\nservile conditions, were seen as threatening not  just<br \/>\nthe racial definition of the nation, but the American<br \/>\nway of life  and, ultimately, White civilization.  In<br \/>\nsuch a situation, White solidarity  became paramount &#8212;<br \/>\nwhich meant that religious differences  dividing<br \/>\nProtestant natives and Catholic immigrants in the<br \/>\nantebellum  period were superseded in the face of the<br \/>\nYellow Peril.  The Irish, accused  of cheapening labor<br \/>\nand introducing foreign elements in the East, were  now<br \/>\nwelcomed into California nativist ranks &#8212; as Whites<br \/>\nfacing a common  threat &#8212; and played a leading role in<br \/>\nspearheading the trade-union,  political, and communal<br \/>\nopposition to the Chinese.<\/p>\n<p>The extent of White  solidarity in the popular classes<br \/>\nwas such that it spurred numerous official  and<br \/>\nunofficial measures to restrict Chinese participation<br \/>\nin the economy  and in other realms of American life.<br \/>\nLocal and state laws, for example,  were passed to<br \/>\nlimit the types of jobs the Chinese could work, the<br \/>\nland  they could own, and the schools their children<br \/>\ncould attend, while White,  especially Irish,<br \/>\nworkingmen not infrequently resorted to violence  to<br \/>\ndrive them from certain trades and from their<br \/>\nneighborhoods.  Then, in  the late 1870s, in a period<br \/>\nof economic crisis, a Workingmen&#8217;s party, led by  an<br \/>\nIrish demagogue, Denis Kearney, was formed in San<br \/>\nFrancisco: Its  principal slogan was &#8220;The Chinese must<br \/>\ngo.&#8221;  Supported by a mass network of  &#8220;anti-coolie<br \/>\nclubs&#8221; and trade unions, the party championed the<br \/>\ncause of  Chinese exclusion.  The state organization of<br \/>\nthe two established national  parties, the Democrats<br \/>\nand the Republicans, each, for the sake of  appeasing<br \/>\nthe pervasive anti-Chinese sentiment the Workingmen<br \/>\nrepresented,  were forced to support its exclusionist<br \/>\npolicies.  But more than transcending  religious<br \/>\ndifferences, the Chinese exclusion movement took aim<br \/>\nat those  large-scale corporate interests (primarily<br \/>\nthe railroads), responsible for  importing Chinese<br \/>\ncontract labor and using it as a leverage against<br \/>\nWhite  workers.  In effect, it targeted not just alien,<br \/>\nbut native threats to the  nation&#8217;s bioculture.  Its<br \/>\negalitarian slogan &#8212; &#8220;We want no slaves  or<br \/>\naristocrats&#8221; &#8212; was thus not simply an<br \/>\nanti-egalitarian affirmation of  the existing racial<br \/>\nhierarchy, but of the right of White men to  the<br \/>\nownership of the land their people had conquered.<\/p>\n<p>The movement&#8217;s  achievements were momentous.  For the<br \/>\nfirst time, national legislation was  passed to prevent<br \/>\nthe immigration of non-Whites to the United States  and<br \/>\nto prevent those already within its borders from<br \/>\nsetting down roots;  White workers succeeded in<br \/>\nfrustrating capitalist efforts to change the  country&#8217;s<br \/>\ndemographic character; and White racial solidarity<br \/>\ntriumphed  over religious differences.  Racially<br \/>\nconsciousness, populist, and at times  anti-capitalist,<br \/>\nthe anti-Chinese movement of the 1870s (whose  spirit,<br \/>\nincidentally, lived on in the national-socialist<br \/>\nnovels of Jack  London) helped preserve the American<br \/>\nWest as a White Lebensraum, representing  one of the<br \/>\nbrightest historical beacons guiding today&#8217;s  White<br \/>\nnationalists.<\/p>\n<p>The third great formative influence shaping  American<br \/>\nracial nationalism came during the First World War.<br \/>\nThe Ku Klux  Klan, which emerged after Appomattox to<br \/>\ndefend Southern Whites from negro  aggression and the<br \/>\nYankee military occupation, was re-organized in 1915<br \/>\nto  address certain changes in American life.  Like the<br \/>\nEuropean fascist  movements of the interwar period,<br \/>\nthis &#8220;Second Klan&#8221; constituted a mass  populist<br \/>\nreaction to the war&#8217;s radical cultural\/social<br \/>\ndislocations.  The  war, for example, imbued the<br \/>\ncentral government with unprecedented powers,  enabling<br \/>\nit to encroach on local communities in ways previously<br \/>\nunknown;  the recently founded Federal Reserve, in<br \/>\ncharge of the money supply, and the  growing influence<br \/>\nof Wall Street and the great corporations assumed  an<br \/>\ninfluence in national life that seemed to come at the<br \/>\nexpense of  independent entrepreneurs and &#8220;the little<br \/>\nmen.&#8221;  At the same time, the war  effort assaulted the<br \/>\nexisting racial, familial, and moral hierarchies.<br \/>\nBlacks in this period acquired a foothold in northern<br \/>\nindustries and  discharged negro soldiers, &#8220;after<br \/>\nhaving seen Paris,&#8221; were no longer willing  to tolerate<br \/>\ntheir caste status.  The year 1919 was one of<br \/>\nunprecedented  racial violence, as negroes challenged<br \/>\nthe existing system of race  relations.  At the same<br \/>\ntime, the middle-class family came under attack.<br \/>\nSuffragettes carried the day with the 18th Amendment,<br \/>\na &#8220;new women,&#8221;  promoted by advertisers and by<br \/>\nHollywood, questioned conventional &#8220;gender&#8221;  relations,<br \/>\ndivorce rates suddenly shot up, and children were<br \/>\nincreasingly  exposed to anti-traditionalist<br \/>\ninfluences.  Finally, there was the specter  of<br \/>\nBolshevism, which appealed to the unassimilated<br \/>\ncommunities of recently  arrived Eastern and Southern<br \/>\nEuropean immigrants and assumed a menacing form  in the<br \/>\ngreat industrial conflicts following the war.  On<br \/>\nevery front,  then, it seemed as if small-town, rural,<br \/>\nand middle-class White America was  in retreat.  But<br \/>\nnot before making a last &#8212; and, for a  generation,<br \/>\nsuccessful &#8212; stand in its defense, for within a<br \/>\ndecade of its  founding, the Klan had rallied 5 million<br \/>\nmembers to its ranks, penetrating  local and national<br \/>\npower-structures as few other anti-liberal movements<br \/>\nin  US history.<\/p>\n<p>Comprised of White, native-born,  anti-immigrant,<br \/>\nanti-Catholic, and anti Jewish elements, particularly<br \/>\nin  the South and the Midwest, this &#8220;Second Klan&#8221; saw<br \/>\nitself as an &#8220;army of  Protestant Americans.&#8221;  As such,<br \/>\nit sought to defend &#8220;pure Americanism,  old-time<br \/>\nreligion, and conventional Protestant morality&#8221; &#8212;<br \/>\nreviving those  religious issues that had earlier<br \/>\ndivided Whites along sectarian lines.  To  this degree,<br \/>\nit was a step back from the anti Chinese movement.  It<br \/>\nwas  nevertheless not the &#8220;reactionary&#8221; movement that<br \/>\nacademic historians make of  it, for like its European<br \/>\ncounterpart, it was both traditionalist and  populist,<br \/>\nfavoring measures that were anti-liberal<br \/>\n(anti-cosmopolitan,  anti-egalitarian, and preeminently<br \/>\npopulist) in spirit but by no means  regressive.  In<br \/>\nthis capacity, it forced the government to close  the<br \/>\nborder to immigrants, it beat back the Black assault<br \/>\non White  hegemony, it let the wheeler-dealers in<br \/>\nWashington and New York know that  their &#8220;progressive<br \/>\npolicies&#8221; would not go unchallenged in the  Heartland,<br \/>\nand it acted as a moral bulwark against the permissive<br \/>\nforces  of Hollywood and Madison Avenue.  Above all, it<br \/>\nupheld a racial standard for  White existence.  Only in<br \/>\nthe late 1920s, after successfully preserving  many<br \/>\ntraditional areas of American life that might<br \/>\notherwise had succumbed  to the race-mixing modernism<br \/>\nof the postwar &#8220;Jazz Age&#8221; did the movement  finally<br \/>\nsubside.<\/p>\n<p>***<\/p>\n<p>The history of American racial nationalism,  as<br \/>\nexemplified by the Second Klan, the Chinese exclusion<br \/>\nmovement, and the  early nativists is a history whose<br \/>\nlegacy cannot but inspire Whites to take  back the<br \/>\ncountry they have lost.  It thus re-affirms our belief<br \/>\nthat we  have nothing to gain by allowing our society<br \/>\nand territory to be overrun by  alien peoples; that<br \/>\nmultiracial communities are unhealthy,  conflict-ridden<br \/>\nones; that multiculturalism, Third World immigration,<br \/>\nand  non-White preferences are a threat to our people&#8217;s<br \/>\nsurvival; that separation  is the sole viable solution<br \/>\nto what is becoming an increasingly ugly  racial<br \/>\nsituation; and that divisive sectarian issues (between<br \/>\nProtestants  and Catholics, Leftists and Rightists,<br \/>\nmodernists and traditionalists, etc.)  serve only the<br \/>\ninterest of our enemies.  Most important of all,  the<br \/>\nheritage of American White nationalism summons us to<br \/>\ndefend the  racial-cultural-civilizational &#8220;nation&#8221; to<br \/>\nwhich our people once belonged and  which, if regained,<br \/>\nmight again distinguish us from the world&#8217;s  less<br \/>\nfavored races.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>Klansmen, Irishmen, and Nativists: The Origins of Racial Nationalism in America by Michael O&#8217;Meara<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[354,271,355,170,183],"tags":[],"class_list":["post-988","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-america","category-michael-omeara","category-real-american-history","category-white-nationalism","category-white-solutions"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.vanguardnewsnetwork.com\/v2\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/988","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.vanguardnewsnetwork.com\/v2\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.vanguardnewsnetwork.com\/v2\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.vanguardnewsnetwork.com\/v2\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.vanguardnewsnetwork.com\/v2\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcomments&post=988"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/www.vanguardnewsnetwork.com\/v2\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/988\/revisions"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.vanguardnewsnetwork.com\/v2\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fmedia&parent=988"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.vanguardnewsnetwork.com\/v2\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcategories&post=988"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.vanguardnewsnetwork.com\/v2\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Ftags&post=988"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}